Saw 'The Silence' yesterday. Here is
The Guardian's review
which gives the background and the story but in its heading needlessly
highlights Liam Neeson who is not that significant in the film. He does a
good job, as always, but that's not the point.
I thought the
film was visually stunning, the script nuanced, the pace slow and
unobtrusive enough to let you think, the directing/acting excellent from
everyone but I agree with the Guardian that Adam Driver would
have been better cast in Andrew Garfield's role. However I don't want
to talk in cinematic terms (am incompetent to do so even if I wanted
to). What interests me most in this film is that it leaves a door open
for philosophical/ethical questions and doesn't attempt to answer them
for you.
Obvious questions regarding religious faith:
If there is a God
why is He/She/It silent in the face of suffering?
Which religious or
non-religious teachings are the kindest, truest, most beneficial to
humans and to the world?
Should any believers try to convert anyone to
their beliefs, whether religious, atheist, political?
What should you do
about beliefs which threaten your existence, your culture, your
identity?
How important are symbols of your beliefs such as images,
relics and other artefacts?
What immediately came up as I left the cinema, got on a bus and took
out my notebook (as usual when a thought seems worth jotting down) was
the concept of heroism. Who is or is not a hero?
The martyrs who endure
unspeakable torture rather than deny their relgious faith?
The soldiers
who accept torture and death in order to defend their country?
The
conscientious objectors who refuse to go to war?
The Jew or Christian or
Muslim or Hindu or member of any other denomination or race who denies it in order to save him/herself and family from extermination?
The child who refuses to snitch on a classmate who has done some
dreadful deed?
The whistleblower who publicly reveals information which
will wreck his/her life but will expose serious wrongdoings?
And what
about symbols: flags for instance. Desecrating their country's flag is
seen as a crime by some, whereas they may see others' veneration of an
image or a book as nonsense.
I don't have answers. But I welcome a film which elicits hard questions.